The re-re-redesign of pray.nd.edu is now live. For a comparison to the version this new iteration is replacing (designed by young, green, inexperienced oak) check out my flickr screen grab for the homepage and the subpage and for that matter, the original green candle page.
The designs
Click the images to check out full size mockups (on flickr).



A look at the process
Wireframe

The wireframe was just to pitch a basic idea to the client. In this case, the major elements of the site where already defined (the candles, the video player, etcetera) because they were already part of the existing site. As you can see, my wireframes aren’t going to win any design awards. My colleague Jim Gosz has been known to refer to these as “priority maps.” In other words, they don’t finalize the design of the page, rather they show what elements will be in the final design and their relative importance.
I’ve found the more loosely I execute a wireframe the less rigorously I am held to it for later stages of the process. This is good because I start to change things almost as soon as I hit the Photoshop step.
“Noli”

I don’t know a better term for this kind of wire-framing. In my brief foray as an architecture student we referred to bird’s eye view outlines that shaded in public spaces of buildings as “Noli Diagrams” so I’ve adopted that term to refer to this step which is sort of in between wireframe and full mock-up. It sort of allowed me to sketch out the various elements and worry more about the overall contrast of the site. One of my really bad design habits is to plow right into the final rendering without really pacing it out.
Initial Client Mock-Up

The first version that went before the client. They “liked it…” the way most clients claim to, but they were concerned that it looked (I’m not making this up), “too much like a website.” Scarily, I knew exactly what they were talking about, though. After some discussion we decided to go for an “airier” feel.
I’m pretty sure that they saw the solid, heavy blue content area at the top of the page and reacted to how it contained the elements within. Also, the buttons on the right really didn’t have to be positioned there. They sort of distracted from the video, which undermined the general idea of the site. If you compare this to the final homepage design linked at the top of this post, the side buttons moved to the bottom allowing the top right area to focus on grotto and mass requests (one of the three most important goals of the site). I got rid of the blue container entirely and subbed in a very light blue background repeater of other, soft focused candles. There are some containment elements to keep the over all composition under control, but for the most part, I tried to push “light and airy” wherever possible.