The (Not so Tragic) Tragedy of the Flickr Commons
Flickr’s Commons is an astonishing repository of cool public domain imagery from such collections as the Smithsonian Institute and the Library of Congress. It’s stated goals (according to the FAQ):
- To increase access to publicly-held photography collections, and
- To provide a way for the general public to contribute information and knowledge. (Then watch what happens when they do!)
Recently I needed an image of Charles Darwin and came across this photo:
Now, I know jack squat about Charles Darwin, so this particular member of the general public can’t do much in the way of adding information and knowledge to this photo. What I am capable of doing, however is removing all those weird black spots and boosting the contrast a bit on the image:

I then reposted this image in my own flickr stream and left a comment on the original with a link back. Nothing has changed at the Smithsonian’s original file.
This seems to me to be a really good way to leave the Flickr Commons better than you found it. If you see an image in need of some retouching, why not clean it up and repost it? Especially if you find another use for it.
At the very least, It’s good retouching practice.
Appendix: I’m not a legal scholar so if I’m breaking several thousand ordinances against Good Samaritan Photoshopping, I’m sure I’ll hear about it soon enough at which point I’ll pull this post and sheepishly explain myself elsewhere on this blog, although I fail to see why anyone who object to crowd-sourced photo retouching. If I’m missing something, I pre-apologize.
-oAk-








